Gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood in small animal surgery

By Lisa Corti, DVM, DACVS, CCRP, North Shore Veterinary Surgery, Andover, Massachusetts, North Shore Community College, Danvers, Massachusetts

Gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood
Gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood 2

(C) https://pixabay.com/de/photos/hand-finger-nagellack-kunst-221630/

From the literature

Anderson SL, Wisnieski L, Achilles SL, Wooton Ke, Schaffer Cl, Hunt yes.
The Impact of Gel Fingernail Polish Application on the Reduction of Bacterial Viability Following A Surgical Hand Scrub.
Vet Surg. 2021; 50 (7): 1525-1532. DOI: 10.1111/VSU.13703


The research…

Sterile surgical gloves are often pierced in surgical interventions, so that effective hand disinfection is essential to reduce the risk of postoperative wound infections. 1-4 Bacteria, which are difficult to remove, can accumulate in particular under the fingernails. 4.5 traditionally it was assumed that nail polish accommodates germs and thus increases the risk of bacterial transmission to patient: inside. 6.7 In both human and veterinary medicine, studies were carried out that examined the influence of nail polish on the bacterial load on fingernails- however, the results were different. 4.5.7-10

In this randomized, controlled study, it was examined how to apply gel nail polish to the number of viable bacteria before and after a surgical hand disinfection-one day and 14 days after a professional manicure by a trained beautician. A total of 40 veterinary students and teachers took part. As part of the manicure, the hands and fingernails were washed 4 % with chlorhexidine gluconate. The nails of both hands were trimmed to <2 mm in length and filed; After the random principle, it was then decided whether gel paint is applied or not.

On day 1 and day 14, before and after a standardized 5-minute, surgical handwash (with the help of a sterile brush and a sponge, both with chlorhexidine gluconate 4 %, as well as a nail cleaner for the area under the nails) the sampling for cultural detection . Cuticula, nail plate and underside of each nail were dabbed with sterile toothpicks and in phosphate-buffered saline solution. Then the samples were cut out on agar plates and the colonian units (KBE/ml) were counted.

The results showed no significant difference in the number of viable bacteria on nails with or without gel nail polish after the surgical standard wash. However, a larger nail length significantly correlated with a higher number of viable bacteria after washing.

... the most important knowledge

Important practical tips:

  1. Gel or acrylic nail polish does not demonstrably increase the risk of viable bacteria after surgical hand disinfection. 5.7.9.10
  2. Nail length is a crucial risk factor for the bacterial load after washing. A length of less than 2 mm is recommended for surgical interventions. 4.5.8.10
  3. Since sterile gloves often perforate during operations, 1-3 influences careful hand disinfection to the development of wound infections. 4.7.11.12
  4. A common standard procedure is the use of a sterile sponge and a brush with 4 % chlorhexidine gluconate, including nail cleaners. 5.11.12
  5. Alcohol-based hand disinfections are becoming increasingly popular in human and veterinary medicine and can- if used correctly according to the manufacturer's information- chlorhexidine and povidone iodine solutions. 4.7.11.12

Frequent questions about gel nail polish & bacterial liability

Does gel or acrylic nails impair sterility in the operating room?

Gel or acrylic nails have long been the focus when it comes to hygiene and sterility requirements in the medical field. The following key questions arise in particular in human and veterinary medicine:
breeding ground for bacteria?
Traditionally, it was assumed that (gel) nail polish or artificial nails could potentially bind germs. Mikroorganisms can settle under the nail plate and along any cracks in the paint or at the transitions of acrylic/gel to the cuticle. Recent studies in veterinary medicine, including the work of Anderson and College published in 2021: However, it has shown that gel nail polish does not significantly increase the germ load after surgical hand disinfection-provided that disinfection is carried out correctly and according to current standards.
The risk of injury due to nail length
is often worn gel or acrylic nails longer than natural nails. The longer the nail is, the more difficult it becomes to effectively clean the area under the nail. In addition, the nail length increases the risk that the nail breaks or a glove tears. Studies show that short nails (<2 mm length) are much easier to keep clean and reduce the number of viable bacteria after disinfection.
The decisive role of hand disinfection
A thorough surgical hand disinfection is and remains the key factor. Whether with or without gel nail polish-if the hygiene protocols are not observed, the risk of surgical wound infections generally increases. The typical protocols include cleaning under the nail with a once pick, brushing hands and forearms to the elbow with an antiseptic solution and consistent compliance with a prescribed exposure time.
Overall, it can be said: gel or acrylic nails are not an increased risk of infection per se , as long as they are applied properly, kept briefly and conscientiously cleaned. Correct and consistent surgical hygiene is crucial to protect the patient: inside in small animal surgery.

How does the nail length affect the number of viable bacteria?

The nail length is a central factor in relation to the number of germs below and around the nails. Studies show:
Higher germ reservoir
Each millimeter more nail length offers bacteria additional niches in which you can settle and multiply. Especially under the free nail edge, there is often a warm -warm microclimate that promotes growth.
Difficult cleaning
with longer nails is more complex to remove dirt and microorganisms. Even when using an antiseptic brush, it is tedious to reach every crack, especially when nails are reinforced with gel or acrylic.
Risk of glove perforation
Longer nails increase the likelihood that surgical gloves tear. If bacteria get into the inside of the glove, an additional source of contamination is created.
Evidence from research
Current examination results, such as that of Anderson et al. (2021), prove that a shorter nail length (<2 mm) correlates with a significantly lower number of bacteria after the surgical hand disinfection. This applies regardless of whether gel paint is worn or not.
Conclusion:
shortening the nails to a maximum of 2 mm is one of the most important preventive measures in surgical practice. Even with optimal hand disinfection, nail length is a factor for effective germ control that should not be underestimated.

Which methods for surgical hand disinfection are most effective and what does this mean for gel nail polish?

There are several recognized procedures for surgical hand disinfection. Essentially, two main categories can be called: traditional washing methods and alcohol -based rubbing . Here is an overview:
traditional washing method
used substances: chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) 4 % or povidon iodine.
Process: keep nails short and clean with a sterile nail pick.
Thorough brushes of the hands, nails, finger spaces and forearms to the elbow over at least 5 minutes.
Finally rinsing under running water.
Advantages: familiar procedure, thorough mechanical cleaning.
Disadvantages: skin irritation through intensive brushes possible; Time required relatively high.

Substances used alcohol -based inserts mostly alcohol -based solutions (e.g. isopropanol/ethanol) with nourishing and filling components, often additionally enriched with chlorhexidine or other antimicrobial active ingredients.
Process: First mechanical cleaning of the nail beds and under the fingernails (often dry brush or nail cleaner).
Dry the hands.
Rub several times with a certain amount of the disinfection solution via the time specified by the manufacturer (e.g. 3 to 5 minutes).
Advantages: faster, more gentle, when used correctly, very effective germ killing.
Disadvantages: requires strict attention to the correct time and quantity scheme.

A hygienically safe result can be achieved with short gel or acrylic nails
. thorough cleaning under the nail is crucial . Gel nail polish should be free of cracks or flaps so that no germs accumulate there.
According to various studies, alcohol-based inserts seem to have a similar effect on bacteria compared to soap or brush methods or sometimes even better. However, it is important that the contact time is adhered to.
Recommendation:
Whether you choose a traditional washing method or an alcohol -based process depends on clinic guidelines, personal preferences and skin tolerance. Gel nails are possible in both cases-if hygiene protocols are consistently followed.

Are there any differences between gel nail polish and conventional nail polish in terms of hygiene?

Yes, there are some aspects in which gel nail polish differs from conventional paint that can play a role for hygiene:
the order and curing
gel paint are usually applied in several layers and hardened under UV or LED light. This creates a harder, less porous surface, which can be less susceptible to splintering.
Conventional nail polish is more porous and can show slight cracks or dislocations, especially with repeated contact with disinfection or cleaning agents.
Liability and durability
gel lacquer often adheres longer and forms a smooth, resistant surface. Theoretically, this can mean that fewer columns are created for germs if the paint layer remains intact.
With ordinary paint, it is more often to split up, which can offer shelter to microorganisms.
Removal and care
GEL -LACK usually requires a special acetone bath or wrap to be completely removed. In the event of improper distance, the nail surface can be damaged, which can lead to grooves and bumps. These rough places in turn offer bacteria possible liability areas.
Traditional nail polish is easier to remove, but has to be applied at shorter intervals.
Effects on the nail health
in the long use of gel lacquer can be dried out of the nail plate or too thinner nails. If porous or cracked nails are not treated correctly, the risk of infection increases.
The bottom line:
Both variants have advantages and disadvantages in terms of durability and potential germ load. condition of the nail surface and the nail length is particularly crucial. An intact gel lacquer, combined with careful hand disinfection, can even be advantageous because less peeling occurs. However, always make sure that there are no cracks or detached areas on the gel paint.

How can I ensure in everyday clinical life that gel nails are not a risk?

The following points are essential if you or your staff want to wear gel-nails in the clinical environment:
to regular control of the nails
pay attention to cracks, splinters and loosely. Even small gaps can offer bacteria an ideal breeding ground.
If damage occurs, the gel paint should be immediately renewed or completely removed.
Professional manicure
A visit to a licensed beautician or a socially trained professional in the team ensures that the gel layers are applied correctly and sealed.
In this way, you reduce the risk of air pollution or unclean edges that promote germs.
Compliance with the nail length,
keep the nails short (<2 mm nail length). Even the best gel lacquer does not replace a decent reduction.
Short nails enable easier and more thorough cleaning with antiseptic solutions.
Strict hand hygiene,
regardless of gel lacquer or natural nails, is indispensable for correct surgical hand disinfection.
Always use a sterile nail pick, an antiseptic brush (or alcohol -based rubber) and adhere to the recommended times (e.g. 3–5 minutes).
Combination with disposable gloves
in small animal surgery are sterile disposable gloves standard. Pay attention to the right size and change gloves immediately in the event of damage.
During long operations, regularly check whether the gloves are still intact.
Continuous training of the team
ensure that all team members are informed about the current study results and protocols on hand hygiene.
Regarding the importance of nail length, disinfection techniques and the correct use of nail polish.
Conclusion:
Gel nails can have an acceptable hygiene and safety level in everyday clinical life as long as certain requirements are met: professional attachment, short nail length, regular control of the paint and correct hand disinfection. In this way you reduce the risk of surgical wound infections and ensure a high standard in small animal surgery.


Summary of gel nail polish & bacterial liability

(1) GEL-NAGELLACK & BATER LIVINATION have increasingly received attention in small animal surgery in recent years because sterile gloves are often perforated during operations and there is an increased risk of infection.

(2) Numerous examinations are devoted to gel nail polish and bacterial livelihood to clarify whether a higher germ load occurs when gel lacquer is worn.

(3) Research shows that gel nail polish & bacterial liability are not necessarily in direct context, provided the surgical hand disinfection is carried out conscientiously.

(4) Nevertheless, it is crucial that gel nail polish & bacterial liability are positively influenced by short nails (<2 mm) and professional, intact paintings, since bacteria can settle in longer or damaged nails.

(5) Microscopic cracks or splintering in the paint play an important role in gel nail polish and bacterial livelihood , since germs can nest there.

(6) For this reason, clinical protocols have established themselves to gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood by thoroughly cleaning the nail edges and using chlorhexidine disinfectants.

(7) An essential aspect of gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood is also the fact that gel or acrylic nails tend to be worn longer, which makes cleaning under the free nail edge.

(8) However, study results suggest that gel nail polish & bacterial liability hardly correlate if the hygiene protocol (nail length, disinfection, testing of the paint intact) are consistently followed.

(9) In practice, people who wear gel nails should pay particular attention to regular controls of their state gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood

(10) Correct hardening under UV or LED light reduces the risk of fine cracks in which bacteria could colonize.

(11) It remains important that gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood in the operating room become particularly critical when gloves tear and germs can get to the patients from the nails.

(12) In order to target gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood

(13) Many clinics enable gel nails if gel nail polish & bacterial liability are checked by strict hygiene standards and no damage to the paint is available.

(14) Studies of staff play a central role in continuing to make gel nail polish & bacterial liability

(15) Overall, the current evidence shows that gel nail polish & bacterial livelihood do not represent an insurmountable obstacle if nail care, hand hygiene and surgical guidelines are consistently observed.

References & further reading

  1. Al-Mohy A, Bhat R, et al.
  2. Kralj n, et al.
  3. Smith BM, et al.
  4. Fight g, et al.
  5. Anderson SL, Wisnieski L, Achilles SL, Wooton Ke, Schaffer Cl, Hunt yes. The Impact of Gel Fingernail Polish Application on the Reduction of Bacterial Viability Following A Surgical Hand Scrub. Vet Surg. 2021; 50 (7): 1525-1532.
  6. Fendler EJ, et al.
  7. Hedderwick Sat, et al.
  8. Pereira LJ, et al.
  9. Pottinger J, et al.
  10. Ernst EJ, et al.
  11. Tanner J, Dumville JC, Norman G, et al.
  12. World Health Organization (WHO).
Scroll up